The Wreck of the Colossus – 10 December 1798

by | Nov 1, 2026 | 1798, The French Revolutionary War 1793-1802 | 0 comments

 

When the Colossus 74 was wrecked in the Scilly Islands during a winter storm in 1798 whilst returning from the Mediterranean, the waters consumed not only the coffin of an ennobled admiral but also scores of Sir William Hamilton’s antiquities.

Towards the end of 1798, it was decided to send the weather-beaten eleven-year-old sail of the line Colossus 74, Captain George Murray, home from the Mediterranean Fleet. In doing so, many prime seamen were removed from the ship to supply her erstwhile consorts, whilst a number of invalids and wounded from the Battle of the Nile were sent aboard in their place. At the time of her departure, she could thus be regarded as a ship in a poor state of repair with a very weak crew.

The Colossus had been commissioned in 1787 and had spent the first three years of her life in the navy as a guardship at Portsmouth under the command of Captain Hugh Cloberry Christian. By 1798 she was already a veteran of the Battles of Lorient and St. Vincent, and during the latter action she had been badly damaged when engaging Vice-Admiral Don Juan de Moreno’s three-decked flagship, the Principe de Asturias 112. Her captain, the 39-year-old George Murray had joined her two years earlier. He was a post captain of sixteen years seniority, who as a young lieutenant in the American Revolutionary War had spent two years as a prisoner in France following the wrecking of the frigate Arethusa 32 on the Breton coast. An even-tempered, placid man, he was held in high regard by Rear-Admiral Lord Nelson amongst others.

As ever, James Gilray had a comment to make on Sir William Hamilton’s appreciation of antiquities.

Taking advantage of the Colossus’ return to England, the British ambassador at Naples, Sir William Hamilton, (whose wife Emma was in the embryonic stages of her relationship with Lord Nelson), consigned a great deal of his personal treasure to her in preparation for his own intended retirement to his country of birth. Arriving at Lisbon from Malta in the third week of November the Colossus collected a convoy, as well as the remains of Admiral Lord Shuldham, the senior officer in the fleet bar Lord Howe, who had recently died in Portugal, and whose wish it had been to be buried in his country of birth. (Given the common seaman’s superstitions pertaining to the transportation of dead bodies aboard ship it must have been with some foreboding, later to be justified, that they lowered the coffin into the hold). Also taking passage aboard the Colossus was Captain John Peyton, late of the Defence 74, who was returning home to recover his health, Captain John Draper, who had been turned out of the Princess Royal 90 by the exacting commander-in-chief of the Mediterranean Fleet, Admiral the Earl of St. Vincent, and George Purvis, the brother of Captain John Child Purvis and late secretary to Lord St. Vincent.

Upon arriving in the Channel, Captain Murray’s convoy encountered strong north-easterly winds, and with his ship low on provisions, and with a regard to her poor condition, he decided to seek shelter in the Scilly Isles. On Friday 7 December the Colossus reached the St. Mary’s Roads in company with eight ships from her convoy; the remainder having parted during the previous two days for Ireland and other ports.

The weather over the weekend continued to deteriorate with the wind becoming ever violent, yet whilst the merchantmen rode out the ever-increasing storm, the Colossus was unable to do so, and her cable parted at 4 p.m. on Monday 10th December. The small bower was let go which temporarily brought her up, but when Captain Murray’s expressed his desire to extricate her from the unfavourable position into which she had drifted, the pilot counselled against him in the belief that they would be unable to weather the rocks. Instead, a sheet anchor was let go and the topmasts were brought down on deck, yet the ferocious wind had not finished with her, and dragging her anchors, she drifted onto the Southern Wells rocks near Samson Island at about 6 p.m. Under normal circumstances, the cannons would have been jettisoned to lighten the ship in an attempt to re-float her, but the shallow waters and thrusting gale prohibited this course of action, lest she be hulled below the waterline by the insufficiently submerged guns. By hauling on the anchor cable the Colossus did temporarily get off the rocks, but the tide then cast her back with an increased velocity and she stuck fast. Despite the best efforts of the men at the pumps, she began to fill with water, and when the rudder broke off at midnight her fate was sealed. Come dawn, the waters were already swirling around her upper deck ports, and she was beginning to break up.

Over the next few hours, and at great risk to themselves, the islanders and local fishermen took the crew off in relays, with the wounded men from the Battle of the Nile going first, and Captain Murray being the last man to leave at about 3 p.m. Somewhat fortunately her only casualty was a quartermaster, Richard King, who had slipped overboard whilst sounding the lead. By Wednesday night the Colossus had tumbled over on to her starboard beam-ends, and on the following day her main mast and bowsprit broke free. With the weather remaining blustery it was not feasible to immediately salvage anything of worth, and consequently Sir William Hamilton’s treasure went to the bottom of the sea, as did Admiral Lord Shuldham’s coffin.

Once the news of the wreck reached Plymouth, the newly commissioned sloop Atalante 16, Commander Anselm John Griffiths, was sent to collect 340 of the crew, whom she delivered to Portsmouth on 23 December. Six days later, the brig Fearless 12, Lieutenant John William Manderson, was also despatched from Plymouth with two transports to collect the stores and goods which by then had been recovered from the wreck. Sixteen cases of the ambassador’s precious Greek vases were amongst the salvaged items, although eight remained below the waves. Admiral Lord Shuldham’s remains were also brought up, to be buried on 9 January 1799 in Wraysbury Church, Buckinghamshire. On 19 January. Captain Murray and his officers were tried at Portsmouth for the loss of their ship and were honourably acquitted.